Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 36:57 — 42.0MB) | Embed
Subscribe Apple Podcasts | Spotify | RSS | More
A business owner deducted a disability insurance premium one year, then stopped for the next two once a back injury made a claim look likely. Three years later, an IRS audit reached back and found the year the premium had been written off. Mark Clark did not write the policy, but he watched what happened next from inside his own office.
The audit did not catch a client hiding money. It caught a client who assumed that skipping the deduction in the years he expected a claim would undo what he had already claimed years earlier. It does not work that way, and the tax bill that follows a mistake like that can run into six figures.
I talked through that case with Mark Clark, CFP, founder and president of Prestige Advisors, Inc., a fiduciary tax-planning practice in Lakewood Ranch, Florida, on this episode of the Income Protection Journal Podcast. Mark has spent 30 years building tax-efficient structures for business owners and high-income professionals, and before he moved into tax strategy he spent years placing disability, life, and benefits coverage directly, which is why he can walk through exactly where a disability premium goes wrong on a return.
The S-Corp Bookkeeping Decision That Determines Whether Disability Benefits Are Taxed
Most of Mark’s clients who run S corporations pay their disability insurance premium through the business. That alone does not create a problem. What determines whether the eventual benefit is taxed is how the payment is booked, on paper, in two places at once.
It has to be indicated not only on the payroll side on the W-2, but it also has to be on the corporate books where it is a distribution and not a premium expense, and that’s the big one for the S corp.
Mark Clark, founder and president of Prestige Advisors, Inc. in Lakewood Ranch, Florida, on the Income Protection Journal Podcast
The premium has to show up as a shareholder distribution in both places, the W-2 and the company’s own books, never as a deducted business expense on either one. Miss either side of that and the CPA has effectively deducted the premium anyway, even if nobody meant to. For most owners weighing disability coverage for business owners, this is the paperwork that gets skipped until a claim forces the question.
What a $15,000 Insurance Premium Can Cost a Business Owner at Claim Time
Mark walked through the numbers on a case close to his own client base. A business owner in a 35 percent tax bracket pays a $15,000 disability insurance premium and deducts it, then goes on claim for a $100,000 monthly benefit.
So that $5,200 tax savings would cause a $100,000 benefit to be taxable at 35%, so that’s a $35,000 tax bill. So you’re saving a $5,200 tax bill to potentially pay a $35,000 tax bill, and that could be year after year.
Mark Clark, a certified financial planner who has spent 30 years advising high-net-worth families, on the Income Protection Journal Podcast
A ten-year claim turns that $35,000 into $350,000, all to protect a deduction worth $5,200 in the single year it was taken. Mark has a phrase for this trade he uses often, asking whether the orange is worth the squeeze. On a disability insurance premium, in his telling, the juice never covers the cost.
Why the IRS Audit Reached Back Three Years for One Disability Insurance Premium
The bookkeeping mistake described above is not always accidental. Mark told me he has watched a business owner try to walk what he calls a tightrope, deducting the premium in a year with no claim in sight and skipping the deduction the moment a claim looks likely. He does not recommend it, and the one time he watched it up close, it did not hold.
They went back three years and they had deducted the premium three years prior. They hadn’t done it the last two years, and the reason they hadn’t done it is because they felt that something was going on with them where they had the disability, and this was a back injury.
Mark Clark, a Qualified Kingdom Advisor who works on the tax structure behind other people’s businesses, on the Income Protection Journal Podcast
The client was already a higher audit risk simply by earning enough to draw attention, Mark said, and the audit reached back far enough to find the one year the premium had been deducted. That single year was enough to make the related benefit taxable, exactly the outcome the client had spent two years trying to avoid.
None of this is about whether a group disability plan reaches an owner’s K-1 income in the first place. A related question, whether a group plan’s covered-earnings definition counts distributed S-corp income toward the benefit at all, is a separate issue covered elsewhere. What Mark is describing here happens after a benefit is already in place: the premium’s own paper trail determines whether that benefit arrives tax-free or gets added to the owner’s income at claim time.
Mark’s advice to every S-corp client is the same, in the end: never deduct the disability insurance premium, because the benefit on the other side is worth far more than the deduction ever was. The tax treatment of a disability benefit is settled years before anyone files a claim, by a decision that looks like paperwork at the time.